Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Ad 1: You’d have to try it yourself, but to me, Obsidian works flawlessly on Mac. As another commeter said, it has a certain VS Code feel to it. No iOS app yet, but I think it’ll come sooner or later — you should keep an eye out.

2nd: Obsidian can transclude whole files or whole sections (afaik). No block-level transclusion, as there isn’t any concept of blocks in Markdown, but that shouldn’t matter much.



It matters enough for me to stay with Roam.

I like how Obsidian is doing PR better than Roam, yet I can’t switch without block transclusion.


I’m curious what do you use block transclusion for? When I used Roam, I did occasionally have a need to link to only a small part of some note, but that happened so rarely that I happily traded that in for the Obsidian-specific features (md based, offline-first).


Most serious writing I do will consist of remixing the same ideas over and over again until it its practically unrecognisable. Roam is the perfect tool for making a collage of text while also keeping a reference to the primary sources.

A simple search on youtube will show you how people use block references btw.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: