Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

You're not necessarily wrong. It's a long held truism that the market can remain irrational longer than you can remain solvent.


If you're right about what the market should, rationally do, and it does something else, you were still wrong.


I think I successfully communicated, and I'm getting upvoted, but my wording was imprecise. Would that I could edit to add: "[...] if you thought that is what it would do."


Either one is right or the market is irrational? Seems like by that logic one can never really be proven wrong.


You can be right, the market can be wrong, and then the market can crash before you can exit the position.

Imagine, for instance, trying to get actual USD (NOT USDT!) for BTC when that fever dream ends.


You can get USD for BTC right now, you've been able to get if for nearly a decade and there have never been as many reputable exchanges as there are now.


The exchanges tend to "go down for maintenance" on any big price swing.


Evidence? I've been in crypto a long time and have never experienced this.

I'm not saying it's never happened, but implying it's some sort of repeating pattern is simply false.



You said they "tend go down for maintenance" on "any big price swings" but were only able to muster one example of one exchange going down "for maintenance" on one price swing (Bitfinex).

The others, as the articles point out, were trade volume related (which is also a problem, but much less sinister).

There's no evidence this is some kind of grand conspiracy like you implied. There's plenty to criticise in Crypto, but little evidence for what you actually claimed.


You're moving the goalposts. A day when everyone is trying to get their "money" out is the definition of a high volume day.


No, I'm not challenging the premise, I'm challenging your framing.

Your comment implied sinister intent: That exchanges go offline at key times in order to scam people.

No evidence was provided of that. The sources you provided point to technical problems that are perfectly understandable during a massive, unpredicted surge in such a technically complex field.


There is a long history of exchanges explicitly scamming people.

Way beyond giving them the benefit of the doubt at this point.


there is no end. crypto will continue to swallow up all the world's capital and you'll be furious at how many leading zeros there are in your BTC-priced paycheck.


that's just delusion and cope. if the price keeps going up for years, then no matter what you think you're wrong. the market isn't being irrational, you are.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: