Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Edit: I’ll avoid commenting on other nations events that I don’t understand.


> It was reported that they were being attacked and beaten in India.

If by "they" you mean the cops, then yes.

See this, for instance: https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/other-states/11-held-...


> You don’t believe there’s a distinction to be made for how the protesters were being treated and what prompted the remarks?

From https://www.dnaindia.com/analysis/news-why-did-justin-trudea...

"Trudeau expressed concern about the Indian security forces' attitude toward these peasant protesters and said that his government has always been a supporter of peaceful protests."

"Sikh vote bank politics matters in Canada. Sikh voters matter to Trudeau's Liberal Party, Conservative Party, and Jagmeet Singh's New Democratic Party. The Sikh population here is close to five lakhs. Sikh separatism or Khalistan has been an essential issue in the relations between India and Canada."

From https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/global-opinions/wp/2018/...

"Sikh, numbering less than half a million, form the largest ethnic group among Indian-origin Canadians. All four of Trudeau’s Indian-origin ministers are Sikh, and Trudeau has publicly boasted how he has more Sikh ministers than Modi. Amarinder Singh, chief minister of the Sikh-dominated state of Punjab and himself a Sikh, has publicly accused Trudeau’s ministers of having sympathies with Canadian Sikh extremists who would like to see Indian Punjab separated from India into the state of Khalistan. Last year, Singh had refused to meet Trudeau’s defense minister, Harjit Singh Sajjan. All four Sikh ministers have recently visited India, and New Delhi would have liked it if Trudeau didn’t bring them along again. But for Trudeau, this trip is all about the Sikh vote in Canada."

"Canada’s position is that it cannot curtail the right to freedom of speech and expression of its Sikh citizens, but New Delhi wants Trudeau to publicly distance himself from Sikh separatists. "

> It was reported that they were being attacked and beaten in India.

The videos and news reports I saw show protestors being violent. They were using tractors to attempt to run over cops, beating cops with batons, walking around with swords etc. Some examples:

Cops jump off wall to escape protestors at Red Fort: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F1qFKUtfvMc

Protestors using tractors against cops: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k7so5TwIMyM

Protestor attacking cop with sword: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rEzMEzzb-94&t=53s

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9feGjEr95nM

If anyone has any videos of the protestors being attacked which would prompt leaders of other nations to condemn, please share. I am from South India, and police using batons/water canons/tear gas is a standard practice even for small protests.


> If anyone has any videos of the protestors being attacked which would prompt leaders of other nations to condemn, please share. I am from South India, and police using batons/water canons/tear gas is a standard practice even for small protests.

In the old days, police would fire live ammo at protests. I remember reading about "XX number of people shot in police firing" growing up all the time. Indian police of old didn't fuck around; they had been taught by the Brits how to crack down, and crack down hard they did.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: