Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Anecdata on QLD everyone knows banana boat is a scam. That sunscreen straight doesn’t work. The cancer council being on here is surprising though


Ok I found this handy chart on a guardian article: https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2025/jun/12/sever...


According to the chart it's not even that bad? Sure, it underperformed its claimed SPF, but it's still above median.


Yeah I think it’s the water resistance, I bet it way below par


"I bet it way below par"

Thanks, that is a great observation

I use Banana Boat sunscreen, they have many different types. The water resistance depends on which type you use


My impression of Neutrogena too, despite them testing well in NZ. Nivea is cheap, basic and actually works.

Absolutely hate mineral ones, literally worst of all worlds - expensive, bad ux and doesn’t work. All while greenwashing. So much so it became my litmus to test people’s literacy.


It works ok for me in Perth :shrug:

I use the spf 50 ‘sport’ version on my legs and arms (not the face, too greasy) and it seems to do the job OK.

I guess if it’s 35 in testing that’s still OK-ish for general use. I do really plaster it on. And as I’m usually doing that before a lot of outdoor work, it draws a further protective layer of sand and dirt to itself…


From the article, it seems like they might all use the same supplier for the active ingredient.


This is what's strange to me, I've never, ever heard anyone here in QLD say "buy banana boat products", it's always said that it is shit though.

So, we, as a community knew to avoid them for an awful long time. I can't be specific about when I heard this first but I'm almost certain some one said this to me in the first 12 months I moved to Brisbane (from the UK) 17 years ago.

So, there's been an urban myth for almost, if not longer than 2 decades. And we're only finding out now that it's true? That's the most surprising part of this to me IMO.

Edit: sentence structure, words.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: