Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

These distros package AGPL software, but are these AGPL packages part of the base install (I don't think so), and does Amazon use this software on production?


>are these AGPL packages part of the base install

For several Amazon Linux AMIs, yes and yes! For Debian, the software are in the main archive, actually.


> For several Amazon Linux AMIs, yes and yes!

Okay, I believe you, I'm not familiar with this. I'd still be interested in knowing which specific AGPL software Amazon would use themselves (note, I'm sure they distribute AGPL software through their distro, that doesn't mean they use it themselves).

> For Debian, the software are in the main archive, actually.

I mentioned the base install. Whatever you get by running deboostrap without parameters, or with a base debian docker container. Of course there's AGPL software in main. main is huge.


So for Amazon, I used to work there and not sure I can talk about specifics, but there was AGPL software used outside of the AMIs but they were approved on a case by case basis. Ghostscript is public and used in the AMIs that are shipped standard, and ofc is used sometimes by Amazon. And if any modifications went out, it was of course gladly republished, but I don't think any forks of AGPL software were being maintained to the best of my knowledge.

>I mentioned the base install. Whatever you get by running deboostrap without parameters, or with a base debian docker container. Of course there's AGPL software in main. main is huge.

No, afaik, unfortunately. That might drastically change how you distribute its base. I was a little unclear but I had meant "No but at least the most common distro ships it in their archive" with my first comment.


Right! Interesting, thanks.

Hadn't thought about Ghostscript!




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: