Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> When exactly were the democrats supposed to "fix" the ACA without compromising?

The Democrats did have full control when they first passed the ACA and they ended up getting in their own way.

But I never said that the Democrats were supposed to fix it on their own. I said both parties are to blame.

It shouldn't require one team have full control for something to happen. That's the real issue. They refuse to work together, and somehow this gets them more support (votes). Both sides. Total shit show.





> The Democrats did have full control when they first passed the ACA and they ended up getting in their own way.

They didn’t. They had to heavily compromise with an Independent.

> After the Finance Committee vote on October 15, negotiations turned to moderate Democrats. Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid focused on satisfying centrists. The holdouts came down to Joe Lieberman of Connecticut, an independent who caucused with Democrats, and conservative Nebraska Democrat Ben Nelson. Lieberman's demand that the bill not include a public option[161][175] was met,[176]

> But I never said that the Democrats were supposed to fix it on their own. I said both parties are to blame.

This doesn’t make any sense, because 99% of Dems have tried to increase access to healthcare, and 99.9% of Repubs have tried to reduce access to healthcare. The sole exception being when McCain provided his vote to not repeal ACA.


> This doesn’t make any sense, because 99% of Dems have tried to increase access to healthcare, and 99.9% of Repubs have tried to reduce access to healthcare.

This is the problem. All conversations about policy lead to "it's the Republicans fault" or "it's the Democrats fault", never about the actual substance of the issue or any attempts to fix the underlying problems.

The fact that both parties think they're "winning the game" right now by shutting down the government is a joke.


I did point out the actual substance of the issue, Repubs don’t want to expand access to healthcare as it would require a wealth transfer, hence they have opposed all efforts.

The Dems (by and large) bring up bills to provide paid parental leave, increase minimum salaries for overtime exempt workers, fund education, increase access to healthcare, and here you are saying they don’t focus on the substance of the actual issues, whatever that means. Meanwhile, the only thing Repubs have done is cut taxes, and block all those efforts.

> The fact that both parties think they're "winning the game" right now by shutting down the government is a joke.

The fact that you would even bring up both parties when one has control of all 3 branches of government is a joke.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: